- Hook, Line, And Sinker$13.95a combo of rustys fried treats! fried shrimp, crab fritters, and calamari served on a bed of onion straws.
- Block And Tackle$9.95a combination of our fried shrimp and fresh calamari on a bed of onion straws.
- Homemade Crab Cakes$9.95two large pan seared cakes stuffed with fresh lump crab meat and served with cilantro-lime sauce.
- Smoked Fish Spread$7.95ask server for availability
- Calamari$8.95(1/2): $6.95a mound of tender calamari hand breaded and fried to perfection, served with marinara and banana pepper rings on the side.
- Feta Artichoke Dip$7.95this creamy dip is served hot with tortilla chips.
- Chicken Wings(20): $10.95(10): $6.95wings dipped in a spicy-sweet sauce, served with celery and bleu cheese.
- Onion Straws 'too Tall'$5.95a heaping stack of our fried onion straws, served with dipping sauce.
- Bellie Banger Shrimp$8.95fried shrimp tossed in a mildly spicy honey mustard sauce
- Mussels$10.95served in white wine or marinara sauce with bread for dipping
- Grouper Bellie Bangers$10.95fried shrimp tossed in a mildly spicy honey mustard sauce
- Crab Corn ChowderBowl: $4.95Cup: $3.95
- Seafood GumboCup: $3.95Bowl: $4.95
- Stone Crab BisqueCup: $4.25Bowl: $5.25
- Dressings: Sesame, Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Honey Mustard, Mango Pineapple, Key Lime Vinaigrette, Greek, Oil & Vinegar
- Side Salad$2.75
- Caesar Salad$7.95
- House Salad$4.95Add Shrimp: $4.95Add Scallops: $5.25Add Steak: $4.95Add Fresh Catch: $5.95Add Grouper 8 Oz: $8.95Add Chicken: $3.95fresh iceberg lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, green pepper, black and green olives, chix peas, and a pinch of fried onion straws
- Rusty's Cobb$10.95(1/2): $8.95a crisp mix of iceberg lettuce, fried gulf shrimp, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, fried onion straws, and cheddar cheese
- Greek Salad$9.95(1/2): $5.95iceberg lettuce, kalamata olives, cucumber, peppers, onion, tomato, chix peas, and feta cheese piled atop a scoop of homemade potato salad. served with greek dressing
- Blackened Shrimp Or Scallop Spinach Salad$10.95fresh spinach, tomato, egg, mushrooms, bacon, & onion. served with key lime vinaigrette
- Rusty's Pot BellyHalf: $16.95Full: $24.95this pot belly has it all! steamed shrimp, oysters, clams, mussels, and a snow crab cluster. corn and potatoes are thrown in too!
- Peel & Eat Gulf Shrimp1/2 Lb: $9.951 Lb: $17.95fresh gulf shrimp steamed in a mix of lemon, olive oil and spices. served hot, you-peel-em style
- Rock Shrimp3 Dz: $20.952 Dz: $14.951 Dz: $8.95add 1/2 dz to any meal for $4.95
- ClamsHalf: $6.95Full: $15.95fresh middle neck clams
- Snow Crab Clusters$16.951 1/2 lbs. served by weight
- Stone Crab Clawsavailable 10/15 - 5/15 - 1lb, served hot or cold with sauce for dipping
- Brandon-travis$22.955oz lobster tail, jumbo sea scallops and fresh shrimp in a rich tomato basil cream sauce over linguini
- Little Joe$16.95a pasta trio with bay scallops, shrimp and mussels, in a light garlic olive oil sauce over linguini.
- Miss Sue$15.95whole littleneck clams combined with fresh chopped clams in light garlic, olive oil and white wine sauce over linguini.
- Carly Sue$12.95a southern favorite! creamy cheese grits, sauteed shrimp, scallions and bacon.
- Little JacquelynAdd Grouper 6 Oz: $8.95Add Steak: $4.95Add Fresh Catch: $5.95$11.95Add Chicken: $3.95Add Shrimp: $4.95Add Scallops: $5.25plump sundried tomatoes and artichoke hearts in a creamy garlic, crushed red pepper sauce over bowties.
- All Specialty Dinners Are Served With A Dinner Salad. All Served With A Side Salad
- Sea Rider u Pick The Catch$17.95Add Fresh Local Grouper: $3.00skewers of grilled shrimp and grilled scallops with a grilled fillet of todays catch or fresh grouper, served with rice.mahi-mahi, tilapia, salmon
- The Kay-lynn$20.95a fresh fillet of local grouper, grilled, topped sauteed onions, peppers, sun dried tomatoes, and feta in a garlic tomato sauce. served on a bed of rice tomatoes, and feta in garlic tomato sauce, served on a bed of saffron rice.
- Thomas Brothers u Pick The Catch$17.95Add Fresh Local Grouper: $3.00todays fresh catch, grilled or blackened. served on a bed of rice pilaf and drizzled with warm lemon-dill sauce. mahi-mahi tilapia salmon
- The Faith$15.95three of our signature crab cakes served on a bed of fried onion straws. served with cilantro-lime for dipping
- Super Queentwo twin lobster tails broiled to perfection with garlic butter. served with rice and fresh veggies
- Chicken Dakota$15.95pan-seared chicken breast topped with sun dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, fresh basil and feta cheese in a lemon cream sauce. served over rice
- Land & Sea$29.95todays featured steak paired with a broiled lobster tail. served with rice, veggies, and garlic bread
- Jacks Shrimp Trio$21.95six peel & eat steamed shrimp, 12 broiled rock shrimp, and bellie banger fried shrimp.
- All Sandwiches Served With The Works And French Fries Add Bacon $0.50, Add Cheese $0.50
- Red Man$14.95Reg: $11.95fresh local grouper from our own boats. fried, grilled or blackened with the works
- Crabber Bob's Softshell Sandwich Blt$10.95a plump softshell crab dusted with flour and fried, topped with onion straws, lettuce, tomato and our secret sauce, add bacon $0.50, add cheese $0.50.
- Linnea C u Pick The Catch$9.95fried, grilled, or blackened. served with the works. mahi-mahi, tilapia, salmon
- Crab Cake Sandwich$9.95an extra large crab cake, pan seared and topped with the works and a side of cilantro-lime
- Shrimp Poboy$8.95$11.95fried shrimp, topped with dill sauce and scallions on a fresh hoagie roll
- Oyster Poboy$11.95$14.95fresh fried oyster bellies topped with dill sauce and scallions on a hoagie roll
- Grouper Poboy$11.95$14.95fresh grouper nuggets, fried, and topped with dill sauce and scallions on a hoagie roll.
- Big Beautiful Burger1/2 Lb: $7.95hand made burger with the works
- Keaton's Big Beautiful Burger$8.951/2 lb burger, blackened, and smothered with grilled onions, bacon and cheese, served on toasted rye bread
- Brother Stevie's Steak Sandwich$7.95fresh grilled steak topped with grilled onions, provolone cheese, and sauce on toasted rye
- Double Eagle$7.95boneless chicken breast grilled or blackened, topped with the works
- The Challenger Grouper Souvlaki$11.95(available until 4pm). fresh local grouper, griller, with tomato, onion, and garlic-cuccumber sauce. served on a fresh grilled pita.
- Tilapia Or Chicken Wrap$8.95With Grouper: $11.95(available until 4pm). grilled or blackened with lettuce, tomato, cuccumber, cheddar cheese, and dill sauce. rolled in a flour tortilla wrap.
- All Seafood Dinners Are Served With Your Choice Of 2 Sides
- Madame Butterfly$15.95fresh gulf shrimp, grilled, fried or blackened
- Johnny OGrouper: $19.95Maahi-mahi: $16.95real local grouper fillet or fresh mahi-mahi fillet, grilled, fried or blackened
- Blue Star$13.95a heaping mound of baby bay scallops hand breaded and fried, served with 2 sides
- Early Out$11.95a southern favorite! fresh mullet fillets dusted with cornmeal and fried
- Miss Wyolene$14.95whole oyster bellies fried to perfection
- The Rogue$18.95a boatyard favorite! a combination of fried shrimp, scallops, mullet and a crab cake, served with 2 sides.
- Galilee$19.95a trio of fried shrimp, baby bay scallops, and mahi-mahi nuggets. substitute grouper for additional $2.00
- Oct. 15th - May 15th. See Server For Availability. No Reorders On Sides Or Salads. Please No Sharing And No Doggies Bags. Last Order 30 Min To Close. All-you-can-eat Meals Are Subject To Availability.
- Julie Ann$25.95mix or match our steamed peel & eat shrimp and fried shrimp. served with french fries and slaw
- Floater Stone Crabs
- Basket Of Bread$2.75
- Garlic Bread$1.50
- Black Beans & Rice$2.75
- Fresh Veggies$2.75
- Hushpuppies$1.00
- Onion Straws$2.75
- French Fries$2.75
- Rice Pilaf$2.75
- Cheese Grits$2.75
- Potato Salad$2.75
- Cole Slaw$1.95
- Corn Casserole$2.75