I have never gotten anything that was' not good. I especially like their Cranberry Walnut Bread& their Olive Oil bread.

Nut roll, cookies, greens roll all delicious! We are new to the area and stopped in after finding them on the internet. Worth the trip and looking forward to trying other goods in the near future. Everyone there was kind and helpful. Add this to your list if you have never been to Two Fat Guys and an Oven you won't be sorry.

Best fish sandwich, ever!!!!

Best fish sandwich, ever!!!!

Best fish sandwich I ever had......the fish was light and the bun, well just kill me now..

Great large fish sandwiches.....The owners are good hardworking people......Stop in and try the cannoli....remember the Godfather, leave the gun, take the cannoli.....Stop in and talk to Drew and Melinda, 2 hard workes, ask them for a sample...buy the fish you won't be dissappointed.

-Two fat guys an a oven .Thank you for all your comments. We appreciate it.

We were extremely pleased with the baked goods we bought while we were in New Castle. (about $100.00 worth) Everything was terrific!

Best pizza I ever had, plus they have a great selection of baked goods- breads , rolls, deserts Can't wait to try it again but wish they were open after 5 since I work until 5 and can't get there Give them a try!

Finally a bakery that is a notch above the rest!!!