- Featuring Linz Heritage Angus and Prime Beef. All steaks are char-grilled over an open flame. Mr. Benny's does not guarantee any meat requested over medium. All entrees include choice of soup or house salad, potato and vegetable
- New York Strip Steak$35.95Boneless, 16 Oz.
- Filet Mignon$34.95Very thick, 10 Oz. Tenderloin
- Ladies Filet Mignon$31.958 Oz., Broiled to Order
- Porterhouse$37.95Juicy, Thick, 24 Oz.
- Bone-in-Ribeye$37.9520 Oz.
- Mr. Benny's Delmonico$33.9518-20 Oz., Boneless Ribeye
- Barbecue Baby Back Ribs$24.95
- Prime Rib (Saturday Only)$34.95
- Veal Piccatta$24.95
- Pork Chop$22.9516 Oz., Grilled, Vesuvio or Marsala
- Rack of Lamb$32.95
- Chicken Tuscany$21.95Sauteed in Olive Oil and Served Over Pasta
- Osso Bucco$34.95
- Petite Frog Legs$23.95Lightly Battered with Lemon Butter
- Shrimp de Jonghe$24.95Baked Shrimp in Garlic Butter, White Wine And Topped With Bread
- Lemon Shrimp$24.95Lightly Battered & Sauteed in Lemon Butter, Delicious
- Filet of Salmon$23.95
- Lake Perch$24.95Boned, Buttered & Lightly Breaded
- Walleye$24.95Pan Fried or Blackened
- Lobster Tail10-12 Oz.
- Turf and SurfOne 10-12 Oz. Lobster Tail and Ladies Filet
- Alaskan King Crab LegsSteamed to Perfection, 1 Full lb. *Split Open For You
- Tomato Bread$8.95
- French Fried Zucchini$8.95
- Barbecued Baby Back Ribs$12.95
- French Fried Mushrooms$7.95
- Sauteed Mushrooms$7.95
- Oysters on Half Shell$12.956 to Order
- Oysters Nicholas$14.954 to Order
- Frog Legs$11.95
- Shrimp Cocktail Supreme$14.95
- Escargot$14.95
- Garlic Bread$5.95
- Shrimp de Jonghe$15.95
- Fried Calamari$10.95