- Classic Egg SaladPint: $9.00Quart: $17.00
- Bullfrog Cole SlawPint: $8.00Quart: $14.00
- Baltimore Brisket2 lbs.: $24.004 lbs.: $40.00
- Bullfrog Chopped LiverPint: $12.00Quart: $22.00
- Smoked Salmon PlatterServes Approx. 10-15: $60.00
- Tuna Fish SaladPint: $12.00Quart: $24.00
- Smoked Chicken SaladPint: $12.00Quart: $24.00
- Roasted Vegetable & Hummus PlatterServes Approx. 10-15: $40.00
- Mini Bagel Platter$2.50(min 20 pieces) Choose among all of our toppings to make your own mini-bagel sliders
- Tier 1: Let's Get Bagels & Schmears$45.00Two Dozen Bagels, Three Large Schmears. Choice of three 8 oz. cream cheeses: Plain, Chive, Salmon, veggie, JalapeƱo or Honey Walnut
- Tier 2: Let's Get Smoked Salmon, Too$100.00Tier 1 Plus: 8 oz. of Scottish Style Smoked Salmon, 8 oz. Pastrami-Crusted Salmon and 8 oz. Whitefish Salad. Includes a platter with all the classic fixings: Tomato, Onion, Capers, Lemon Wedges, cucumber & Chopped Egg
- Tier 3: Let's Also Get House-Smoked Meats$150.00Tier 1 & tier 2 plus: Choice of Three (8 oz. of each): Pastrami, Corned Beef, Roasted Turkey, Neuske's Liverwurst or Hummus. Includes a platter with our house made sauerkraut, tomato, onion, lettuce and several condiments
- Route 11 Potato Chips20 1 oz. Bags: $20.00
- Rick's Classic Sour Brooklyn PicklesQuart: $10.00
- Zeke's Boxed Premium Coffee96 oz.: $25.00Ten 12 oz. Cups, Cream & Sugar provided upon request
- Add a bag of Route 11 Potato Chips and a fresh dill pickle to any Bagelwich for just $2
- Our Signature Recipe Artisan Bagels, Hand Rolled, Boiled & Baked Daily on Premises. Varieties include: Plain, Sesame, Everything, Poppy, Salt and Onion
- Bagels & BialysSingle: $1.50Baker's Dozen (13): $18.00
- Bagel or Bialy with Butter$2.50
- Bagel or Bialy with Plain Cream Cheese$3.00
- Bagel or Bialy with Chive/Scallion Cream Cheese$3.50
- Bagel or Bialy with Jalapeno Cream Cheese$3.50
- Bagel or Bialy with Honey Walnut Cream Cheese$3.50
- Bagel or Bialy with Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese$4.00
- Bagel or Bialy with Seasonal Fruit Jams & Preserves$3.00
- Bagel or Bialy with Goat Cheese & Honey$4.00
- Bagel or Bialy with Hummus$4.00
- Egg & Cheese$5.00Cheddar, Muenster or Swiss
- Bacon, Egg & Cheese$6.00
- Sausage, Egg & Cheese$6.50Cheddar, Muenster or Swiss
- Corned Beef or Pastrami Egg & Cheese$7.00Cheddar, Muenster or Swiss
- TBA$7.00Turkey, Bacon, Avocado with Sriracha Mayo
- Hummus, Avocado & Sprouts$7.00
- Tuna Melt on a Bialy$8.00Tomato and cheddar
- House-Smoked Salmon Sandwich$8.50Cream Cheese, Tomato, Red Onion, Capers & Black Pepper
- Smoked Salmon BLT$8.00Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Cream Cheese
- Reuben$9.00Corned Beef, House-Made Sauerkraut, Swiss & 1000 Island
- Whitefish Salad$8.00Tomato, Red Onion, Capers & Cream Cheese
- The Wurst$7.00Neuske's Liverwurst, Tomato, Onion, Mayo & Black Pepper
- The Natitude$9.00Hot Pastrami, Swiss & Dijon Mustard Sauce
- The Oriole$8.50Hot Baltimore Brisket, Muenster & Jus
- We proudly start with the highest quality fish and meats, then cure, brine, smoke, braise, slow-roast and/or season all of them
- Scottish Smoked Salmon3 oz.: $10.00
- Pastrami-Crusted Smoked Salmon3 oz.: $10.00
- Smoked Whitefish Salad6 oz.: $8.00
- Pastrami6 oz.: $10.00
- Corned Beef6 oz.: $10.00
- Baltimore Brisket2lbs: $35.004lbs: $60.00
- Hickory-Smoked Turkey8 oz. for: $10.00
- Breakfast Sausage$2.00
- Turkey$2.00
- Pastrami$2.00
- Corned Beef$2.00
- Smoked Salmon$4.00
- Tuna Fish Salad$4.00
- Bacon$1.00
- Avocado$1.00
- Tomato$0.50
- Hummus$1.00
- Onion Jam$0.50
- Double Cheese$1.00
- Egg$1.00
- Butter$0.50
- Goat Cheese$1.00
- Plain Cream Cheese$0.50
- Chive/Scallion Cream Cheese$0.75
- Jalapeno Cream Cheese$0.75
- Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese$1.50