- All of Anastasia's sandwiches are served with your choice of chips or pretzels and a pickle spear
- Club SandwichFull: $9.50Half: $5.50Toasted wheatberry bread with turkey, tavern ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and our special club sauce
- Café FiletFull: $9.50Half: $5.50Filet of roast beef, tomato, cucumber, and horseradish sauce on crusty French baguette
- Northern Italian Turkey Salad SandwichFull: $9.50Half: $5.50Our gourmet salad on French baguette with Provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato
- BLTFull: $9.50Half: $5.50Toasted wheatberry bread with crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo
- Veggie PitaFull: $9.50Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, bell peppers, roasted sweet red peppers, onion, and Colby cheese on fluffy pita bread
- The HoosierFull: $9.50Half: $5.50Tavern ham, and melted Swiss cheese, bacon, cucumber, and mayonnaise on a multigrain baguette
- The Philly – Hot!Full: $9.50Half: $5.50Filet of roast beef, Pepper Jack cheese, bell pepper, red onion, pepperoncinis, and herb vinaigrette toasted on a French baguette
- Italian Grinder – Hot!Full: $9.50Half: $5.50Tavern ham, salami, Provolone cheese, bell pepper, red onion, and herb vinaigrette toasted on a French baguette
- Choice between: Meat and Salad
- Start with Bread!Baguettes: French, Multigrain, Sourdough, Sliced Wheatberry, Honey Wheat Wrap, Fluffy Pita (Full only)
- Add Some MeatTavern Ham, Filet of Roast Beef, Mesquite Smoked Turkey, Oven Roasted Turkey, Hard Salami
- A SaladChicken Salad, Egg Salad, Tuna Salad
- Pick a CheeseColby, Baby Swiss, Provolone, Pepper Jack
- Choose VeggiesLettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Bell Pepper, Black Olives, Pepperoncini
- Top it OffSpicy Deli Mustard, Mayonnaise, Horseradish Sauce, Herb Vinaigrette
- Chicken WaldorfFull: $9.50Half: $5.50Chunks of Chicken Breast, Pineapple, Celery, Apple, Grapes, Mandarin Oranges, and Walnuts Tossed in a Lime Poppy Seed Dressing
- Sicilian Pasta SaladFull: $9.50Half: $5.50Colorful Rotini Pasta, Carrots, Black Olives, and Bell Peppers Tossed in a Creamy Herbed Sicilian Dressing
- Northern Italian Turkey SaladFull: $9.50Half: $5.50Julienne Strips of Turkey Breast, Onion, Roasted Sweet Red Pepper, and Fresh Parsley Marinated in a Virgin Olive Oil and Red Wine Vinegar Dressing
- Salad SamplerFull: $9.50Try a sample of all three gourmet salads!
- Plated or in a Wrap~Full size only $9.95
- Original Grilled Chicken SaladServed with choice of dressing
- Raspberry Chicken Salad
- Caesar
- Curried
- CajunServed with choice of dressing
- Grilled Chicken Pasta SaladServed with choice of dressing
- Greek Salad$9.50A taste of the Mediterranean! Garden greens topped with cucumber, bell pepper, red onion, pickled beet, pineapple, authentic Feta cheese, and Kalamata olives. Served with original Greek dressing
- The Vineyard$9.50a Beautiful Bed of Greens Topped with Grapes, Walnuts, Swiss Cheese, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, and Your Choice of Dressing
- Garden Green Salad$7.50$5.00Assorted Greens, Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Bell Peppers, Red Onion. Choice of Dressing
- Caesar Salad$8.50$5.00Romaine, Fresh Parmesan Reggiano, Croutons, and House Caesar
- Homemade and Baked Fresh! Served with Chef's choice baguette bread and fruit garnish. By the Slice $6.50. Take home a whole pie $39.95
- Bacon and CheddarIt's Bacon and Cheddar need we say more?
- Four CheeseA delicious blend of Cheddar, Provolone, Swiss and Colby cheeses
- Spinach FlorentineAn elegant combination of Spinach and Swiss Cheese
- Signature Iced Tea$2.50Classic, Green, Ginger Peach, Blackberry Sage
- Fruit Smoothies$3.99Assorted Flavors
- Root Beer Float$3.99
- Italian Crème Soda$3.99Assorted Flavors
- Mocha Frappo$4.95
- 20oz. $2.50
- Coke
- Diet Coke
- Sprite
- Root Beer
- Add a Flavor Shot to any drink ~ $0.50
- House BrewsTall (12oz): $2.50Grande (16oz): $2.75Mungo (20oz): $3.25
- LatteGrande (16oz): $4.00Hot or Iced
- CappuccinoGrande (16oz): $4.00
- MochaGrande (16oz): $4.50
- Chai Tea LatteGrande (16oz): $4.00Hot or Iced
- Baguettes$4.50French | Multigrain | Sourdough
- Peanut Butter$1.75
- Chocolate Chip$1.75
- Snickerdoodle$1.75
- Oatmeal Raisin$1.75
- Chocolate Wow$1.75
- Fresh Daily Homemade SoupsCup: $4.50Bowl: $5.95Pint: $7.95Quart: $15.75Anastasia's Cafe takes great pride in offering the Finest Homemade Soups! Check the board by the door or visit our Facebook page daily for the Soups of the Day. Comes with bread
- Box Lunch$12.00Your choice of any Full size sandwich. Includes a small side of Sicilian Pasta Salad and a delicious brownie for dessert. Great for business meetings!
- Don't forget your Beverage! Choose two for $9.50
- Half Sandwich
- Cup of Homemade Soup
- Side Gourmet Salad
- Side Garden Salad
- 1 ScoopChicken, Egg (Gluten Free), or Tuna Salad