- Soft Drink$2.00
- Famous Plum St. ChiliStarting At: $3.75Topped with cheddar cheese and onions.
- House SaladStarting At: $4.50Mix lettuce with tomatoes, onion, cranberries and cheddar cheese.
- Chef Salad$6.95Freshly cut ham and turkey served on top of mix lettuce with tomatoes, onions, cranberries and cheddar cheese.
- Famous Plum St. Hoagie$6.95A combination of spicy capicola, hard salami, provolone cheese, crisp lettuce, tomato and onion with Italian dressing or mayo. Served with pickles and choice of side.
- Steak Hoagie$6.95Your choice of pizza or mushroom sauce, tomato, onion, pickle and provolone cheese. Served with pickles and choice of side.
- Quesadilla$5.75Served with sour cream and salsa.
- Chili Burrito$6.95Plum St. chili, cheddar cheese, onions, tomato and lettuce served with sour cream and salsa.