- Cheese OnlyL: $10.50M: $8.75S: $7.50
- 1 ItemL: $11.75M: $9.75S: $8.25
- 2 ItemL: $13.00M: $10.75S: $9.00
- 3 ItemL: $14.25M: $11.75S: $9.75
- Additional ItemsL: $1.25M: $1.00S: $0.75
- Extra SauceL: $0.50M: $0.50S: $0.50
- Everything PizzaL: $16.75M: $13.75S: $11.25pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, green peppers, onions
- Veggie PizzaL: $16.75M: $13.75S: $11.25mushrooms, green peppers, banana peppers, onions, black olives
- Pepperoni
- Mushroom
- Italian Sausage
- Onion
- Green Peppers
- Capocolla Ham
- Black Olives
- Green Olives
- Fresh Tomatoes
- Fresh Garlic
- Anchovies
- Extra Cheese
- Banana Peppers
- Pineapple
- Papa Rotolo's Chef Salad$4.75tossed salad with capocolla ham, pepperoni, banana peppers and provolone cheese
- Mama Rotolo's Tossed SaladQuart: $3.75Pint: $2.75lettuce, tomato and italian dressing
- Dinners Include, Pint of Salad, 2 Rolls and Our Special Blend of Grated Parmesan and Romano Cheese Add a Meatball $1.25
- Home-Made Lasagna$6.75
- Rigatoni with 1 Meatball$6.50
- Home-Made Spaghetti with 1 Meatball$6.50
- Home-Made Spaghetti with Meat Sauce$6.75
- Home-Made Spaghetti with Mushrooms$6.75
- Dinners Include, 4 Meatballs, Quart of Salad, 4 Rolls, and Our Special Blend of Grated Parmesan and Romano Cheese Add a Meatball $1.25
- Family Spaghetti$16.00
- Family Rigatoni$16.00
- Italian Sub$4.75provolone cheese, salami, pepperoni, banana peppers, capcolla ham, lettuce, tomato
- Super Sub$5.75italian sub with extra ham, salami and provolone cheese
- Veggie Sub$4.75provolone cheese, mushrooms, onion, green peppers, banana peppers, tomato
- Meatball Sub$4.753 meatballs on a sub bun
- Meatball Sub with Provolone Cheese$5.253 meatballs on a sub bun
- Garlic Bread$2.00
- Garlic Bread with Provolone Cheese$2.50
- Spaghetti SauceQuart: $5.00Pint: $3.00
- Meat SauceQuart: $6.50Pint: $4.25