- Bread: Regular, Multigrain-Thin Cut, Multigrain, Regular-Thin Cut. Cheese: Blue Cheese, Cheez Whiz®, Feta, Swiss, Provolone
- Turkey ClubTurkey Club: $7.90Bg Turkey Club: $9.35All-natural, hand-pulled, slow-roasted turkey with Nueske's bacon and cheddar cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and mayo on multigrain
- Grilled Chicken & CheddarGrilled Chicken & Cheddar: $6.35Bg Grilled Chicken: $7.80All-natural chicken breast hand-sliced with melted cheddar cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and mayo on multigrain
- Dressings: Balsamic Dressing, Buttermilk Ranch, Fat Free Vinaigrette, Potbelly Vinaigrette
- Powerhouse (Powerhouse Salad)$8.15All-natural grilled chicken breast, fresh avocado, zippy hummus, hard-boiled egg, crisp cucumber and grape tomatoes on a bed of fresh spinach
- Mediterranean (Mediterranean Salad)$8.15All-natural grilled chicken breast, artichoke hearts, chickpeas, roasted red peppers, crisp cucumbers, diced red onion, tomatoes, crumbled feta cheese and Italian seasoning on a bed of fresh romaine, iceberg and spinach. Cheese: Blue Cheese, Feta, Cheddar, Provolone, Swiss
- Craft Your Own Mac & CheeseMac & Cheese Side: $3.60Mac & Cheese Cup: $4.75Mac & Cheese Bowl: $6.30Creamy, three-cheese mac and cheese with your choice of 2 premium toppings including bacon, chili, Potbelly hot peppers, mushrooms or roasted red peppers. Toppings: Chili, Mushrooms, Bacon, Roasted Red Peppers, Hot Peppers
- Broccoli CheddarBroccoli Cheddar Cup: $3.60Broccoli Cheddar Bowl: $5.00Creamy cheese soup with tender pieces of broccoli and carrots
- Coleslaw$1.70
- Potato Salad$1.70
- Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie$1.55A Potbelly favorite! Freshly baked oatmeal chocolate chip cookie
- Sugar Cookie$1.55Freshly baked sugar cookie