- Fried Cheese Sticks$6.99Fried Mozzarella Cheese
- Blue Crab Claws4 Oz.: $9.998 Oz.: $16.99Lightly battered and fried golden brown
- Fried Mushrooms$6.99Fresh mushroooms hand breaded and fried golden brown
- Fried Onion RingsHalf Order: $5.49Whole Order: $7.49Fresh onion rings hand breaded and fried golden brown
- Potato Skins$7.99Idaho potato shells topped with real bacon bits and cheddar cheese, server with sour cream and chives
- West Indies Seafood Dip$7.99A blend of shrimp, crabmeat, green peppers, celery, green onions and homemade italian dressing. served with tortilla chips
- Appetizer Combo$15.99A combination of chicken tenders, Mozzarella Cheese Sticks and Crab Claws
- Fresh Gulf Grouper$13.99Strips of Fresh Grouper lightly battered and fried golden brown
- Baked Onion Soup$4.99A creamy onion soup topped with toasted bread and provolone cheese
- Old Mill GumboCup: $4.99Bowl: $6.99Spicy combination of vegetables, whole Blue Crab Claws, shrimp and shredded crabmeat served with white rice
- Certified Angus Beef
- Ribeye10 Oz.: $18.9914 Oz.: $25.99Certified Angus Beef ribeye char-grilled with our signature steak sauce
- New York Strip12 Oz.: $19.99Certified Angus Beef New York strip loin char-grilled with our signiture steak sauce
- Prime Rib10oz.: $19.9914oz.: $26.99Certified Angus Beef Prime rib slow cooked in our special oven and served with au jus
- Filet Mignon6 Oz.: $20.999 Oz.: $26.99Certified Angus Beef tenderloin char-grilled with our signature steak sauce
- Beef Kabob$16.99Chunks of Certified Angus Beef tenderloin, fresh mushrooms, peppers, onion, zucchini and tomato wedges char-grilled with our signature steak sauce
- Chopped Steak10oz.: $11.99Certified Angus Beef steak ground in our own kitchen then char-grilled with our signature steak sauce and topped with sauteed mushrooms and onions
- Old Mill Cheeseburger$8.99Half-pound Certified Angus Beef burger ground in our own kitchen, char-grilled and served with lettuce, tomato, pickle, and onion
- Shrimp & Grits$13.99Seasoned steamed shrimp on a bed of creamy grits served with parmesan sauce
- Scallops$13.99Sweet bay scallops broiled or fried
- Blue Claw Dinner4 Oz.: $14.998 Oz.: $19.99Lighty battered and fried golden brown
- Seafood Lovers Platter$18.99Fresh Gulf Gouper, scallops, and shrimp broiled or fried
- Jumbo Gulf Shrimp$14.99Fresh Gulf shrimp served fried, balcken or char-grilled
- Stuffed Flounder$17.99Flounder broiled with a spicy southern style crab stuffing
- Fried Founder$16.99
- Shrimp & Grouper Combo$22.99Jumbo Gulf Shrimp and Fresh Gulf Grouper
- GrouperWhole: $27.99Half: $19.99Fresh Gulf Grouper Cut in-house daily and served char-grilled, blacken, fried
- Stuffed Grouper$31.99
- Salmon$18.99North American Salmon Char-Grilled or blacken, served with dill sauce
- Crab Cake Dinner$19.99Two Maryland style crab cakes broiled and served with a lemon-butter sauce
- Seafood Alfredo$15.99Sautee shrimp and scallops smothered with Alfredo Sauce on a bed of linguine
- Baked Potatos
- French Fries
- Broccoli
- Grilled Veggie Skewer
- Baked Sweet Potato
- Garden Fresh Salad
- Fried Chicken Tenders$10.99Fried Golden brown tenderloin of chicken served with honey mustard or sweet'n sour sauce
- Chicken Parmesan$15.99Fresh chicken breast topped with a meaty red sauce and provolone cheese served over pasta
- Grilled Chicken$13.99Fresh breast char-grilled, topped with Swiss cheese, mushrooms and onions
- Chicken Alfredo$15.99Sliced grilled chicken breast covered with Alfredo sauce on a bed of linguine
- Steak & Shrimp10oz Ribeye: $22.996oz Filet Mignon: $24.99Char-grilled steak and gulf shrimp served grilled or fried
- Steak & Grouper10oz Ribeye: $29.996oz Filet Mignon: $31.99char-grilled steak and Grouper served grilled or fried
- Prime Rib & Shrimp$23.99Our delicious ten-ounce prime rib with a choice of grilled or fried Gulf Shrimp
- Steak & Crab Cake10oz Ribeye: $22.996oz Filet Mignon: $24.99Char-grilled steak with a broiled Maryland-style crabcake
- Chopped Steak$10.99Certified Angus Beef steak ground in our own kitchen then char-grilled with our signature steak sauce and topped with sauteed mushrooms and onions
- Prime Rib Sandwich$10.99Five ounces of medium-well Certified Angus Beef prime rib and Provolone Cheese served on French roll with au jus
- Ribeye$14.99Eight-ounce Certified Angus Beef Ribeye Char-Grilled with Our Signiture Sauce
- Fried Chicken Tenderloin$8.99Five Fresh Chicken Tenders Fried Golden Brown
- Grilled Chicken Breast$9.99Five ounce grilled chicken breast served with sauteed mushroom, onions, and Swiss cheese
- Large Gulf Shrimp$9.99Eight wild-caught Gulf Shrimp fried golden brown or char-grilled
- Chopped Steak$10.99Certified Angus Beef ground in our own kitchen then char-grilled with our signature steak sauce and topped with sauteed mushrooms and onions
- Ribeye$14.99Eight ounce Certified Angus Beef ribeye char-grilled with our signature sauce
- Fried Chicken Tenderloin$8.99Five Fresh Chicken Tenders Fried Golden Brown
- Grilled Chicken Breast$9.99Five-Ounce grilled chicken breast served with sauteed mushroom, onions, and Swiss cheese
- Large Gulf Shrimp$9.99Eight wild-caught Gulf Shrimp fried golden brown or char-grilled
- Prime Rib Sandwich$9.99Five ounces of medium-well Certitied Angus Beef prime rib and Provolone Cheese served on French roll with au jus
- Cheeseburger4oz: $4.99Certified Angus Beef char-grilled and served with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle
- Child's Steak4oz: $4.99Certified Angus Beef char-grilled with our signature steak sauce
- Chicken Fingers3 tenders: $4.99Fried tenderloin of chicken served with honey mustard sauce
- Fried Shrimp5 Gulf Shrimp: $4.99Gulf shrimp lightly battered and fried golden brown
- Old MIll Bread Pudding$4.99Homemade bread pudding served alamode and drizzled with barbon sauce
- Key Lime Pie$4.99Creamy blend of tropical key limes in a graham craker crust, topped with whipped cream
- Old Mill Pie$5.99Vanilla ice cream in a chocolate crust topped with our special mocha sauce and whipped cream
- Peanut Butter Pie$5.99A blend of crunchy peanut butter, vanilla ice cream and smooth topping all frozen in a chocolate crust