- Jumbo Wings8 Pcs: $5.95hot, mild, bbq or breaded w/ ranch dressing
- Panzarotti$4.50W/ One Topping: $5.50
- Breadsticks$4.95W/ Mozzarella Cheese: $6.95w/ marinara sauce
- Chicken Tenders$5.95w/ honey mustard or bbq sauce
- Meatball Plate$5.95w/ 4 meatballs, green peppers and french bread
- Pizza Puff$3.00
- Garlic Bread$2.50
- Garlic$3.50w/ mozzarella
- Pizza Bread$3.50W/ One Topping: $4.00
- Feench Fries$2.50W/ Cheddar Cheese: $3.50
- Cheddar Chili Fries$4.50
- Baked Potato$2.00w/ sour cream
- Potato Skin3 Pcs: $5.25w/ cheddar cheese and bacon
- Mozzarella Sticks6 Pcs: $4.50w/ marinara sauce
- Spinach Bread W/ Mozzarella Cheese$3.50
- Jalapeno Poppers6pcs: $4.50choice of cheddar or cream cheese
- Breaded Calamari Rings$4.50
- Breaded Onion Rings$3.50breaded mushrooms or cauliflower
- Mixed Veggie Plate$6.50includes above 3 w/ ranch dressing
- Chili Con Carne$3.25
- Cole Slaw12 Oz: $2.0024 Oz: $3.50
- Dressings: Italian, 1000 Island, Garlic, Caesar, Ranch, Bleu Cheese. Grilled Chicken On Any Salad Add $2.50
- Minestrone Soup20 Oz: $3.50
- Chicken Noodle Soup20 Oz: $3.50
- Cream Of Broccoli Soup20 Oz: $3.50
- Papa Joe's AntipastoSmall: $5.95Large: $6.95
- GardenSmall: $3.95Large: $5.50
- CaesarSmall: $4.95Large: $6.50
- Mixed GreensSmall: $4.95Large: $6.50
- SpinachSmall: $4.95Large: $6.50
- Tomato & OnionSmall: $4.95Large: $6.50
- Any W/ Meatballs, Sausage Or Mushrooms Add $2.50. Any Baked W/ Mozzarella Cheese Or Meat Sauce Add $1.50. Includes Garlic Bread And Grated Cheese
- Spaghetti$6.25w/ marinara sauce or fresh garlic & olive oil
- Mostaccioli$6.25
- Linguini$7.75w/ red or white clam sauce
- Ravioli Meat Or Cheese$6.50
- Tortellini Meat Or Cheese$6.75
- Stuffed Jumbo Shells Ricotta Filled$7.25
- Lasagna$7.75meat or spinach
- Fettucine Alfredo$9.25W/ Choice Of Chicken, Broccoli Or Shrimp: $11.25
- Papa Joe's Fettucine$12.25w/ sausage, green peppers and mushrooms
- Sweet Peppers Or Hot Giardiniera Add $0.50, Mozzarella Cheese Or Garlic Bread Add $1.00, Deluxe Includes French Fries & Cole Slaw Add $2.00
- Papa Joe's Beef$5.95w/ red sauce, sweet peppers, mozzarella cheese
- Italian Beef$4.75
- Cheezy Beef$5.75
- Bbq Beef$5.00
- Italian Sausage$4.50w/ red sauce or natural gravy
- Italian Meatball$4.50
- Combo-italian Beef & Sausage$5.75
- Grilled Chicken$5.50
- Breaded Chicken$5.00
- Chicken Or Veal Parmigiana$5.50
- Italian Submarine Cold Or Hot$5.75
- Pizza Burger$5.50
- Hamburger1/3 Lb: $4.50
- Double Hamburger$5.50
- Cheeseburger1/3 Lb: $4.50
- Double Cheeseburger$6.00
- Pepper & Egg$3.95
- Includes Garlic Bread, French Fries Or Steak Fries, And Cole Slaw. Any Substitution Such As French Bread, Baked Potato And Salad Is Available Upon Request
- Chicken$7.95fresh oven baked, bbq or fried
- Bbq Ribs12 Slab: $9.95Full Slab: $15.25
- Jumbo Shrimp7 Pcs: $9.9512 Pcs: $15.50
- Eggplant Parmigiana$7.95w/ spaghetti instead of potato
- Veal Parmigiana$8.95w/ spaghetti instead of potato
- Chicken Parmigiana$9.95w/ spaghetti instead of potato
- Cheese, Sausage, Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion.specialty Pizzas Are Priced For Thin Crust Available In All Styles. Pizza Toppings - Italian Sausage, Eggplant, Green Peppers, Green Olives, Anchovies, Hot Giardiniera, Pepperoni, Broccoli, Mushrooms, Garlic, Onionspin, JalapeNos, Potatoes, Spinach, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Pineapple, Canadian Bacon. Additional Charge Toppings - Ricotta, Bacon, Shrimp, Ground Beef, Chicken, Roast Beef.
- 4-way Favorite10": $9.2012": $11.4514": $13.7016": $15.9518": $17.951/4 sausage, 1/4 green pepper, 1/4 mushroom, 1/4 onion
- Sicilian Style10": $9.4512": $11.9514": $14.4516": $16.9518": $19.45tomato, basil, garlic, olive oil
- Windy City Classic10": $10.7012": $13.4514": $16.2016": $18.9518": $21.70sausage, pepperoni, mushroom
- Hawaiian Style10": $10.1012": $12.7014": $15.3016": $17.9518": $20.60canadian bacon, pineapple
- Vegetarian10": $11.9512": $14.9514": $17.9516": $20.9518": $23.95spinach, tomato, green pepper, mushroom
- Western10": $11.3512": $14.2014": $17.0516": $19.9518": $22.85sausage, bacon, onion, bbq sauce or tomato sauce
- Meat Lover's Delight10": $13.2512": $16.4514": $19.6516": $22.9518": $26.25sausage, pepperoni, bacon, ground beef
- Bbq Chicken10": $8.8512": $11.2014": $13.5516": $15.9518": $18.35breaded or grilled chicken marinated in bbq sauce
- Pizza Toppings - Italian Sausage, Eggplant, Green Peppers, Green Olives, Anchovies, Hot Giardiniera, Pepperoni, Broccoli, Mushrooms, Garlic, Onionspin, JalapeNos, Potatoes, Spinach, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Pineapple, Canadian Bacon. Additional Charge Toppings - Ricotta, Bacon, Shrimp, Ground Beef, Chicken, Roast Beef.
- Cheese10": $6.9512": $8.9514": $10.9516": $12.9518": $14.95
- 12 Cheese & 12 Choice10": $7.6012": $9.7014": $11.8516": $13.9518": $16.10
- One Topping10": $8.2012": $10.4514": $12.7016": $14.9518": $17.20
- Papa Joe's Favorite10": $11.4512": $14.2014": $16.9516": $19.7018": $22.45
- Pizza Toppings - Italian Sausage, Eggplant, Green Peppers, Green Olives, Anchovies, Hot Giardiniera, Pepperoni, Broccoli, Mushrooms, Garlic, Onionspin, Jalapenos, Potatoes, Spinach, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Pineapple, Canadian Bacon. Additional Charge Toppings - Ricotta, Bacon, Shrimp, Ground Beef, Chicken, Roast Beef.
- Cheese10": $7.9512": $9.9514": $11.9516": $13.9518": $15.95
- 12 Cheese & 12 Choice10": $8.6012": $10.7014": $12.8516": $14.9518": $17.10
- One Topping10": $9.2012": $11.4514": $13.7016": $15.9518": $18.20
- Papa Joe's Favorite10": $12.4512": $15.2014": $17.9516": $20.7018": $23.45
- Pizza Toppings - Italian Sausage, Eggplant, Green Peppers, Green Olives, Anchovies, Hot Giardiniera, Pepperoni, Broccoli, Mushrooms, Garlic, Onionspin, JalapeNos, Potatoes, Spinach, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Pineapple, Canadian Bacon. Additional Charge Toppings - Ricotta, Bacon, Shrimp, Ground Beef, Chicken, Roast Beef.
- Cheese10": $8.9512": $10.9514": $12.9516": $14.95
- 12 Cheese & 12 Choice10": $9.6012": $11.7014": $13.8516": $15.95
- One Topping10": $10.2012": $12.4514": $14.7016": $16.95
- Papa Joe's Favorite10": $13.4512": $16.2014": $18.9516": $21.70
- Pizza Toppings - Italian Sausage, Eggplant, Green Peppers, Green Olives, Anchovies, Hot Giardiniera, Pepperoni, Broccoli, Mushrooms, Garlic, Onionspin, JalapeNos, Potatoes, Spinach, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Pineapple, Canadian Bacon. Additional Charge Toppings - Ricotta, Bacon, Shrimp, Ground Beef, Chicken, Roast Beef.
- Cheese10": $10.9512": $12.9514": $14.9516": $16.95
- 12 Cheese & 12 Choice10": $11.6012": $13.7014": $15.8516": $17.95
- One Topping10": $12.2012": $14.4514": $16.7016": $18.95
- Papa Joe's Favorite10": $15.4512": $18.2014": $20.9516": $22.70
- Pizza Toppings - Italian Sausage, Eggplant, Green Peppers, Green Olives, Anchovies, Hot Giardiniera, Pepperoni, Broccoli, Mushrooms, Garlic, Onionspin, JalapeNos, Potatoes, Spinach, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Pineapple, Canadian Bacon. Additional Charge Toppings - Ricotta, Bacon, Shrimp, Ground Beef, Chicken, Roast Beef.
- Cheese10": $11.9512": $13.9514": $15.9516": $17.95
- 12 Cheese & 12 Choice10": $12.6012": $14.7014": $16.8516": $18.95
- One Topping10": $13.2012": $15.4514": $17.7016": $19.95
- Papa Joe's Favorite10": $16.4512": $19.2014": $21.9516": $23.70
- Tiramisu$3.50
- Cannoli Sweet Ricotta Filled Pastry$2.50
- Eli's Cheese Cake Plain Or Chocolate Chip$2.50
- Pastry Nuggets Sugar Or Powder Coated$2.00
- Pudding Cake Double Chocolate Chip$1.50