- Bermuda Triangle Onion Soup$9.75Caramelized Bermuda Onions, Shallots, Leeks, Garlic, & Thyme topped with Melted Fontina Cheese
- Cuban Black Bean$7.00With Plantain Salsa
- Toddy's ChowderCup: $9.50Bowl: $10.50Ask Your Server about Today's Chowder
- Add the Following to Your Salad: Grilled Salmon $12, Shrimp $7, Chicken $5
- House$8.00Mixed Greens, Feta Cheese tossed in a Cranberry Vinaigrette
- Macaw Caesar$9.00Romaine tossed in Traditional Caesar dressing with Croutons
- Macadamia Nut Goat Cheese$12.00Mixed Baby Greens, Poached Pear, Truffle Vinaigrette & Reduced Balsamic
- Calamari Salad$14.00Warm tender Calamari sauteed in Lemon, Herbs & Olive Oil served over a bed of Mixed Greens & Spinach
- Portobello Tower$14.00Grilled Mushroom, Tomato, Blue Cheese, served atop Edamame & Spinach Compote & Whipped Potatoes
- Clams$14.00White Wine, Anchovy, Parsley Butter with Toasted Bread
- Calypso Calamari$12.00Fried & tossed in a Honey Ginger Tamari Sauce garnished with Scallion Cilantro
- Mussels$14.00Corn & Kielbasa Velouté with Toasted Bread
- Tuna Tetaki$14.00Seared Ahi Tuna, Island Spices, Wakame Salad, Wasabi & Pickled Ginger
- Tuna Tartar$15.00Soy marinated Ahi Tuna, Chili Lime Aioli & Fresh Guacamole
- Trinidadian Crab Cakes$14.00Pan Seared over Roasted Chipotle Remoulade
- Shrimp Cocktail$12.005 Shrimp with a House Made Cocktail sauce
- Chicken Liver Pâté$11.00With Cornichons, Olives, Mustard & Toasted Bread
- Three Nut Encrusted Salmon$28.00Cedar Wood Roasted Salmon topped with Pecans, Walnuts, Cashews & Fruit Salsa, Rice & Vegetables. Suggested Wine Pairing: Long Valley Ranch Chardonnay, Monterey, California
- Seared Gulf Grouper$36.00Citrus & Thyme Jumbo Lump Crab, Curried Cauliflower, Brussels Sprouts. Suggested Wine Pairing: Secret Vines Chenin Blanc, Loire Atlantic, France
- Tuna Madagascar$28.00Seared Ahi prepared RARE, finished with a Beurre Blanc, Pickled Ginger, Wakame Salad served with Rice & Vegetables. Suggested Wine Pairing: Vins Descombe White Bourgogne, Burgundy, France
- West Indies Bouillabaisse$36.00Calamari, Mussels, Clams, Shrimp, White Fish, Salmon & Potatoes in a Coconut Seafood Broth. Suggested Wine Pairing: Stangeland Pinot Noir, Willamette Valley, Oregon
- Sea Scallops$36.00Pan Seared Diver Scallops with a Saffron, Tarragon Mustard Sauce, Cranberry & Orange Black Rice. Suggested Wine Pairing: Sidewood Sauvignon Blanc, Adelaide Hills, Australia
- Roasted Chicken$18.001/2 Chicken Roasted with Lemon, Rosemary & Olive Oil served with Mashed Potatoes & Vegetables. Suggested Wine Pairing: Stangeland Pinot Noir, Willamette Valley, Oregon
- Curried Chicken$22.00Dark Meat served with a Curry Sauce & Peach Chutney with Rice & Vegetables. Suggested Wine Pairing: Vins Descombe Brouilly Beaujolais, France
- Down Island Chicken$22.00Seared Chicken Breast finished in a Red Wine Cream Reduction, Kielbasa with a Large Shrimp, Whipped Potato & Vegetable. Suggested Wine Pairing: Bleu de Mer 100% Merlot by Bernard Magrez
- Caribbean Duck$29.00Crispy Half Duckling Roasted, Par Boned with a Tamarind Rum Sauce served with Whipped Potatoes & Vegetables. Suggested Wine Pairing: Lakewood Vineyards Long Stem Red, Fingerlakes, New York
- Steak Caribe$46.00Jimmy P's Kobe Rib Eye, Island Spices, Red Wine Demi Glace, Onion Hay, Baked Corn Casserole & Vegetables. Suggested Wine Pairing: Sidewood Shiraz, Adelaide Hills, Australia
- Pork Porterhouse$26.00Pork Porterhouse with a Green Peppercorn Mushroom Sauce, Whipped Sweet Potato & Vegetable. Suggested Wine Pairing: Secret Vines Tempranillo, Ribera del Duero, Spain
- Vegetarian Bowl$18.00Marinated Mushroom, Vegetable Stir Fry with Orange Cranberry Black Rice. Suggested Wine Pairing: Lakewood Vineyards Cabernet Franc, Finger Lakes, New York