- Spencer's offers USDA prime and natural steaks and chops. Only 2% of beef produced in the U.S. Is graded prime. Our natural steaks are pasture raised without hormones or antibiotics. Steaks are aged 21 days and cooked in 1600° infrared broilers to ensure the natural beef juices are sealed in under a thin charred crust
- Spencer's Steak$43.0016oz boneless rib eye
- New York Strip$44.0014oz center cut
- Filet Mignon$39.00$49.008oz or 12oz barrel cut
- Grilled Colorado Lamb$39.00Jalapeño mint chimichurri, smoked potato gratin
- Conch Chowder$9.00Ciabatta crouton, bird pepper rouille
- Caesar Salad$12.00Romaine hearts, parmesan crisp
- Baby Iceberg Wedge$12.00Bacon, cherry tomato, blue cheese vinaigrette
- Spencer's Salad$13.00Field greens, dried cherries, maytag blue cheese, balsamic vinaigrette
- Heirloom Tomatoes$15.00Burrata, watermelon, basil, aged balsamic
- Jumbo Lump Crab Cake$16.00Whole grain mustard remoulade
- Tuna Tartare$15.00Soy gelee, sesame crisp, togarashi dressing
- Chilled Colossal Gulf Shrimp$18.00Bloody mary cocktail sauce
- Jumbo Lump Crab & Béarnaise$9.00
- Smothered in Mushrooms & Onions$6.00
- Blue Cheese Crust$5.00
- Today's CatchOnly the freshest fish key west has to offer
- Seared Snapper$29.00Coconut red curry sweet potatoes, saffron aioli
- Caribbean Key West Pinks$28.00Jerk spices, papaya jam, tostones
- Ahi Tuna$32.00Coriander crusted tuna, roasted tomato caponata, olive basil gastrique
- 72 Hour Beef Short Rib$29.00Mac & five cheeses, cabernet sauce
- Grilled Atlantic Sword$29.00Mango miso glaze, key west pink shrimp salsa
- Spiny Lobster Tail$36.00Stuffed with shrimp and conch mousse, jicama slaw, pineapple chutney
- Plantain Crusted Grouper$32.00Key lime chipotle glaze, sautéed callaloo greens
- Zucchini Galette$25.00Sundried tomato pesto, balsamic glaze, tomato bruschetta
- Sautéed or Creamed Spinach$8.00
- Grilled Asparagus$8.00Charred lemon
- Mushrooms$8.00Herb butter
- Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes$8.00
- Crispy French Fries$8.00
- Mac & Five Cheeses$9.00
- Spencer's Loaded Hash Browns$12.00Applewood smoked bacon, sharp cheddar, sweet onions, chive sour cream