A small town gas station. It fulfills its purpose. Decent subs and small deli, there is a respectable craft brew selection now as well.I noticed a review about bad gas from 2011 and thought I would update this as the owners have put in new tanks. I fill up there regularly and have had no problems the last 3 years.

I was hunting in Otsego County during the first week of December, 2010. Needed gas and was on County 16 at the time heading for I88, so stopped here to fill up. The truck was empty, so it took a big load. The price was high, but still needed fuel to get home. By the time I got to Sidney, my truck was running real bad. I found out the problem was water in the gas. I had to spend the night in Sidney and a local truck stop did the repairs to my truck. I won't be fueling up in Garrattsville again.