We apologize for the inconvenience

The people search feature on Superpages.com is temporarily unavailable. You can still search for people on yellowpages.com since Yellow Pages and Superpages are part of one company.

You will be automatically re-directed to People Search on yellowpages.com in .

Please note our privacy policy has changed. To view the policy, please go to https://corporate.thryv.com/privacy/

Details

We are your local Progressive Authorized Agent. We provide Free Insurance Quotes for Auto Insurance, Umbrella Insurance, Home Insurance and more.

General Info

Progressive and Aarp Authorized Agents. Voted best insurance agency on Long Island 4 years in a row. Save up to 37 pcton your auto, home, business and life insurance. Home insurance for coastal houses at great rates.

HoursCLOSED NOW
Regular Hours:
Mon - Fri
Sat
SunClosed

Contact Info

Phones:

Main - 631-698-4776

Fax - 631-698-6091

ExtraTollFree - 800-573-7572

Address:
530 Horseblock Rd Farmingville, NY 11738
Email:

Reviews

5
45 Reviews
Select your rating
Write a Review
anonymous

03/03/14

5.0

Have been wanting to change insurance policies for awhile but life gets in the way. Then Sandy happened and had some roof damage. Began the long battle with the insurance co. Still fighting! Well long story short my insurance company (one here on the island) short changed me and dropped my policy due to roof. Went to my local Allstate agent in RVC who policy was with and she was USELESS. At the same time the LI Press came out again with their ranking giving Cotten first place. Well I finally called them and should have done it 3 years ago. I called and spoke to Margaret who was a pleasure to deal with. Discussed the situation with roof and having it fixed in spring after all this snow. She said no problem I'll get some quotes and sure enough it was done quick, efficient and CHEAPER. I'm saving 6 hundred on the same coverage! Go figure. Call them

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/23/14

5.0

Margaret Crafa was by far the most helpful insurance agent I have ever dealt with. I needed workers compensation coverage and was having a problem with State Insurance Fund. She was able to get me coverage immediately and save me a lot of time and aggravation I would highly recommend Cotten Coverage.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/22/14

5.0

Cotten Coverage Was Been Great All These Years Helping Me Out Time To Time Especially Tatiana. By Navarro

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/22/14

5.0

Cotten Coverage Was Been Great All These Years Helping Me Out Time To Time Espceially Tatiana

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/22/14

5.0

Cotten Coverage Was Been Great All These Years Helping Me Out Time To Time Espceially Tatiana

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/22/14

5.0

Cotten insurance has been very help full over all this years .. Especially Katherine who has been a great help.....

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/22/14

5.0

Cotten insurance has been very help full over all this years .. Especially Katherine who has been a great help.....

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/21/14

5.0

Cotten Coverage is by far the best insurance company I have been with. Always attentive with their clients. Always on top of their clients policies. The girls always have smiles on their faces which always makes me feel welcomed!!!! -The McCaffrey

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/21/14

5.0

Cotten Coverage is by far the best insurance company I have been with. Always attentive with their clients. Always on top of their clients policies. The girls always have smiles on their faces which always makes me feel welcomed!!!! -The McCaffrey

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/19/14

5.0

I totally recommend Cotten Coverage Insurance, my agent Tatiana is very helpful and professional. Always a pleasure to do business with them! They treat you like family!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/19/14

5.0

My agent Tatiana is very helpful and professional, always a pleasure to do business at Cotten Coverage Insurance, they treat you like familyI highly recommend them!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/19/14

5.0

Margaret has always helped me with everything from getting better rates to helping me with my claim from the Sandy Storm..Highly recommend her and Cotten Coverage.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
B
bwagne1

02/14/14

1 Reviews0
5.0

Joe Carroll is the best insurance agent around! He is very reliable, easy to talk to, & just a pleasure to do business with. I recommend Cotten Coverage to everyone and make sure they call Joe.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/14/14

5.0

Cotten Coverage has been great since day one. The customer service is 110% always. Katherine is who I always deal with for my billing and she's always pleasant and always helps me with any of my concerns. Keep up the great work Cotten. I will definitely refer Cotten Coverage to friends and family. Not only did they save me money on my insurance. The customer service is tremendous.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/12/14

5.0

Changing to Cotton Coverage has been by far the wisest choice my family has ever made. The "Insurance Doctor" has helped my family save a ton of $$ over the years and his care for his customers is unlike any other broker I have ever dealt with. He is very personable and polite, very easy to deal with. Cotton Coverage is lucky to have an agent like James! Nicole P

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/12/14

5.0

I highly recommend Cotten Coverage. I have been dealing with Gena for 5 years and she provides excellent customer service. Not only has she saved me money but she has helped me with claims and DMV issues from another brokerage. Without any doubt in my mind calling Cotten Coverage was the right choice! Frank L

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

02/12/14

5.0

I highly recommend Cotten Coverage. I have been dealing with Gena for 5 years and she provides excellent customer service. Not only has she saved me money but she has helped me with claims and DMV issues from another brokerage. Without any doubt in my mind calling Cotten Coverage was the right choice! Frank L

Was this Review helpful to you?0
K
Kellymgorham

02/11/14

1 Reviews0
5.0

I highly recommend Cotten Coverage for all of your insurance needs. Jennifer Williams has been a tremendous help with all of our personal insurance coverages. I have recommended her to numerous friends and have always gotten great feedback from them as to how helpful she was. She is great to work with and has excellent follow-up.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
T
Thomas C.

02/10/14

1 Reviews0
5.0

A+++ Jennifer Williams For a great job getting us insurance

Was this Review helpful to you?0
S
Sue W.

02/10/14

1 Reviews0
5.0

Five Stars for Jennifer Williams who wrote a commercial Insurance policy for me. Great Ins. Agent!! Thank you so Much Jennifer !!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Categories
Business & Commercial Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Insurance, Renters Insurance
Payment Options
check, debit, master card, visa, cash
Brands
Aarp, American Commerce, Chubb, Fidelity, Foremost, Geico, Hartford, Kingstone, Mapfre, Merchants, Narragansett, National Grange, Progressive, Safeco, Tower, Travelers, US Liability Insurance
Location
At the intersection of Horseblock Rd and Hanrahan Ave. 1/10 of a mile East of the Farmingville Post Office
Languages
Hebrew, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish
Associations
Professional Insurance Agents, Independent Insurance Agents
Data provided by one or more of the following: Thryv, Data Axle, Yext.