Love the pizza here. Real NY pizza and they are quick to deliver it. The staff are nice enough, they rarely get orders wrong.

Best pizza in Brewster, only surpassed by the penne ala vodka and the friendly atmosphere. I highly recommend Portofino for a great meal.

Best pizza and wedges in Brewster. Only bad part is that when you order a small and you don't know that small means individual pizza. 10$ for an individual pizza is far too high. A med is 1 dollar more. Wish I had known that before I ordered two small pizzas.

Pizza is good would never step foot in there again after they wouldn't let me Granddaughter use the bathroom, long story short I got her home she was rushing to get to the bathroom and fell down the stairs. If you have small kids think twice before you go in there....

Grandma's pizza at Portofino's (Brewster) is unbelievable ! Garlic knots are delicious.

I work near the Portofinos and they have the best pizza in brewster so far.