Great pizza! Thin crisp crust. When you ask for well done it shows up at the house well done.

By far best pizza in Bayville! All their food is amazing. They are fair also they made a mistake on my order and not only did they include free garlic knots but completely deliveredme a whole new dinner!!! Excellent!!!

Tony's pizza is the best new pizza in town, if you like a friendly atmosphere and great food then this is the place , if you want a grouchy owner and someone who does not care about customers just money then go to Frankie's

Tonys isn't just the best pizza in bayville. It's the best in NJ. This tiny pizza place pumps out the best food around. The staff is super nice and Tony himself talks to you when you go in there. Best pizza best service!!!

Fast friendly service. Most gravy in the area is bland right out of the can. Not this place ! The crust is very good as well. I get my pie thin and extra crispy, perfect every time.

Great food!!! Pizza is better than any around and they deliver!!!

My husband and I have ordered food from Tony many times since he has opened. Everything is absolutely delicious! The cheesesteak melts in your mouth, the buffalo chicken pizza is awesome, and the cheesecake is yummy!! Try it, you will love it!